Equal Pay Laws: Bridging the Gender Wage Gap
Understanding the Gender Pay Gap and Equal Pay Laws
The gender pay gap, a well-documented issue, continues to persist across various industries and professions, with women generally earning less than men. Debates on whether this gap arises from discrimination or occupational choices have been ongoing. However, it's essential to recognize that if within the same organization, men and women receive unequal pay for similar work, it could potentially violate both federal and state equal pay laws.
As a woman earning less than male counterparts with similar roles, you may have grounds for a sex discrimination claim and rights protected under equal pay laws. Employers should also familiarize themselves with these laws. For more information, explore our frequently asked questions regarding equal pay laws.
Closing the Gender Gap-Equal Pay Act Requirements
The Federal Equal Pay Act and the Massachusetts Equal Pay Act aim to bridge the gender wage gap by prohibiting compensation discrimination—ensuring that men and women receive equal or comparable pay for similar work. In Massachusetts, the criteria revolve around comparable work, which is slightly broader than the federal requirement for equal work. Comparable work typically involves jobs that demand similar skills, effort, and responsibility, all performed under similar working conditions.
Certain exceptions permit employers to pay men and women differently. These exceptions include seniority systems, merit-based systems, or systems that measure earnings based on production quality or quantity. Additionally, a "catch-all" exception under federal law allows pay differences for "any factor other than sex."
Notably, the Massachusetts Equal Pay Act does not include this catch-all exception but permits pay differences related to job-related travel or educational requirements. It also prevents seniority systems from penalizing employees for time spent on pregnancy-related or family and medical leave. Employers can establish an affirmative defense to a Massachusetts Equal Pay Act claim by conducting a good faith equal pay audit.
Equal Pay Laws and Other Discrimination Laws
In numerous instances, the protections provided by Equal Pay laws overlap with existing discrimination laws. For instance, employers consistently paying women less than men may violate laws against sex discrimination and equal pay laws simultaneously.
It's essential to bear in mind the overlapping rights, especially for women of color. The wage gap is more pronounced for people of color compared to white women. While equal pay laws do not directly address pay gaps based on race, color, or national origin, discrimination based on any of these factors is illegal. If a woman of color earns less than white colleagues for equal or comparable work, she may have grounds for a claim under these laws.
Proving Equal or Comparable Work
Equal or comparable work encompasses roles that require substantially similar skills, effort, and responsibility, performed under similar conditions. It does not mandate identical job duties for pay equity determinations.
Neither federal nor state equal pay laws set precise criteria for allowable pay differences in cases of equal or comparable work. An employer facing an equal pay claim may cite a "merit system" as a justification for unequal pay. However, such a system may rely on subjective criteria that impact women's earnings compared to men.
Pay differences based on production quality or quantity could also conceal discrimination, particularly if women are assigned more challenging or less profitable tasks, such as sales territories. In many business settings, employers may control access to opportunities, leading to varying performance, even on objective metrics.
Under federal law, the "catch-all" exception permits pay differences based on "any factor other than sex." Consequently, an equal pay claim often involves competing facts, with the employer presenting multiple justifications for unequal pay.
Proving the Pay Gap
Comparing compensation plans can be straightforward in roles where employees receive fixed salaries. However, complexities arise when compensation includes bonuses or incentive pay.
An effective starting point involves analyzing total compensation from all sources, but this information is not always readily available before initiating a lawsuit—unless coworkers are willing to share their salary details.
Massachusetts has addressed this concern by prohibiting employers from preventing employees from sharing compensation information.
Time Limits for Bringing an Equal Pay Claim
An important distinction between sex discrimination claims and equal pay claims is the statute of limitations. In Massachusetts, the statute of limitations for discrimination claims is 300 days from the discriminatory act. In contrast, a federal equal pay claim has a two-year statute of limitations, and a Massachusetts equal pay claim has a three-year statute of limitations. Therefore, if you miss the deadline for a sex discrimination complaint, you may still have time to challenge your compensation due to these extended time frames.
In the past, many women with unequal pay were unable to bring claims because the pay disparity persisted for more than two or three years. The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, enacted in 2009, addressed this issue by considering each unequal paycheck as a new violation. Consequently, even if you received unequal pay for several years, you can still file a claim as long as some of the affected paychecks fall within the statute of limitations.
Need Help With an Equal Pay Problem?
Need Some Preliminary Feedback About an Equal Pay Issue?
Our Solutions Roadmap is a quick and easy way to share some information about your situation and your goals and receive preliminary feedback from a member of our team. Use the button below to get started- it is 100% confidential and 100% free.
How our Employment Lawyers Can Help
Our experienced team can provide legal guidance and representation if you believe you're facing pay discrimination. Contact us to discuss your situation and take steps toward fair compensation. You can use the button below to schedule a call back from a member of our team, or give us a call at 781-784-2322.