slnlaw
  • Home
  • Estate Planning
    • Massachusetts Wills and Trusts
    • Why You Need an Estate Plan
    • Massachusetts Estate Tax
    • Inheritance Tax
    • How to Make an Estate Plan
  • Employment Law Solutions
    • Employment Law MA
    • Employment Termination
    • Sexual Harassment at Work >
      • Sexual Harassment in a Small Business
      • Sexual Harassment and Non Disclosure Agreements
      • Sexual Harassment and Remote Work
    • Wage and Hour Laws
    • Independent Contractor Law
    • Non Compete Agreements >
      • Are non competes enforceable
      • Massachusetts Non Compete Act
      • Pre 2018 Massachusetts Non Competes
    • Equal Pay Act
  • Business Law Solutions
    • Small Business Law
    • Business Contract Basics
    • Civil Suit Defense
    • Legal Issues for Start Ups
    • Trademark Basics
    • How to Incorporate
    • Sale of Business
  • Attorneys
    • Emily Smith-Lee >
      • 2018 Lawyer of the Year
    • Jenna Ordway
    • Rebecca Rogers
    • Stowell Simonton
    • Elijah Bresley
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Contact
Call (781) 784-2322

Non Compete Not Enforceable

Non competes are only enforceable in Massachusetts if they are necessary to protect a legitimate business interest of the employer. Below is an example of a non compete case we defended because the restrictive covenants did not protect a legitimate interest.

Unenforceable Non-Compete Case Study: Background

Client F was an analyst for a market research company in Massachusetts. He did primarily back office work collecting and analyzing data. He did not interact with customers or prospective customers. His work also did not involve trade secrets or a proprietary methodology.

Client F was offered a job by a company in California that provided similar services in a similar market. The Massachusetts company sent a cease and desist letter to him and his new employer. The letter threatened to sue both of them to enforce the non compete.

Unenforceable Non-Compete Case Study: Strategy and Outcome

Client F contacted us after he received the cease and desist letter. We reviewed his documents and interviewed him. Based on this review, we concluded that he did not have any customer relationships that would impact the employer's goodwill.

It also did not appear that the work he did was informed by any confidential methodologies. Instead, the analysis he did was based on established data analysis techniques and his own experience.

In addition, the new job was for a California employer. California had passed a law refusing to enforce non competes unless necessary to protect trade secrets.

We first attempted to reach a resolution with the old and new employers. The former employer, however, was unwilling to accept a compromise that would limit Client F's contact with prior clients for the restricted period.

Client F was forced to take action. His new employer wanted reassurance that they would not be dragged into a lawsuit in Massachusetts. We had worked collaboratively with them to find a solution, but they needed more than that. His former employer refused to cooperate. We filed a complaint seeking a declaratory judgment that the non compete was unenforceable.

We argued that the agreement was unenforceable under California law. We also argued that it was unreasonably restrictive given the absence of a legitimate business interest to protect. Client F did not have any meaningful customer relationships. He also was not privy to trade secrets or confidential information that would justify an enforceable non compete agreement.

Once the former employer realized they had to defend a lawsuit, we reached a resolution. Client F was released from his non compete with certain reasonable restrictions, and started his new job with the California company.

Need Help With a Non Compete Agreement?

Contact Us
MA Non-Compete unenforceable employment lawyer slnlaw
Unenforceable MA Non-Compete employment attorney slnlaw
Noncompetition agreement unenforceable in MA employment lawyer slnlaw

Unenforceable Non-Compete Case Study: Takeaways

There are a number of lessons to be learned from this example that may help you if you are facing a dispute over a non compete agreement

  • You don't have to wait for your employer to sue you. Sometimes it is to your advantage to be the first one to go to court, as it was in this case.
  • Your lawyer should be prepared to speak with your new employer to try to reach a compromise without litigation. But if that is not possible, they should be prepared to initiate litigation if necessary.
  • If you are effectively blocked from starting a new job by the threat of a lawsuit, it may make sense for you to act first.
  • It is always worth examining the specifics of your role with your former employer. If stopping your from working does not protect the employer from something the law recognizes, the agreement may not be enforceable.

Can We Help You?

We have years of experience representing people in non compete lawsuits in Massachusetts state and federal courts, as well as responding to cease and desist letters, and we would be happy to help. You can use the button below to schedule a call back from a member of our team, give us a call at  781-784-2322, or fill out our web form  to let us know a little more about your situation.
Schedule a Free Information Call

Sharon MA

46 South Main Street
​Sharon MA 02067

(781) 784-2322
Greater Boston Referral Resources
slnlaw solutions
Refer a Friend
slnlaw publications and interviews
​slnlaw privacy policy
Chester MA
26B Main Street
Chester MA 01011
(413) 667-2322
Western MA Referral Resources

  • Home
  • Estate Planning
    • Massachusetts Wills and Trusts
    • Why You Need an Estate Plan
    • Massachusetts Estate Tax
    • Inheritance Tax
    • How to Make an Estate Plan
  • Employment Law Solutions
    • Employment Law MA
    • Employment Termination
    • Sexual Harassment at Work >
      • Sexual Harassment in a Small Business
      • Sexual Harassment and Non Disclosure Agreements
      • Sexual Harassment and Remote Work
    • Wage and Hour Laws
    • Independent Contractor Law
    • Non Compete Agreements >
      • Are non competes enforceable
      • Massachusetts Non Compete Act
      • Pre 2018 Massachusetts Non Competes
    • Equal Pay Act
  • Business Law Solutions
    • Small Business Law
    • Business Contract Basics
    • Civil Suit Defense
    • Legal Issues for Start Ups
    • Trademark Basics
    • How to Incorporate
    • Sale of Business
  • Attorneys
    • Emily Smith-Lee >
      • 2018 Lawyer of the Year
    • Jenna Ordway
    • Rebecca Rogers
    • Stowell Simonton
    • Elijah Bresley
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Contact